Salerno`s Cafe in Old Forge

Food was great service was terrible. Waited 15 minutes to have someone to come over then order was wrong. The server was a long time employee and I wonder why

My picky eater (7 year old) took one bite and asked to come back. She usually picks the cheese off the pizza. It's stayed in and she ate almost three slices. Huge victory for Salerno's on getting return business from us. One bite and it was over!

Wonderful food, friendly pleasant staff.

Wonderful staff. I enjoy the booths in the bar area. They belong in the pizza capitol.

Pretty looking pie but the cheese blend taste like White American cheese. The crusts is what makes it easy to eat. If they had fresh mozzarella cheese option this would a new family favorite

Excellent pizza. My son loves the tuna spaghetti. Orange shallot dressing is out of this world delicious!

Always good ther. best white pizza in O forge

Great neighborhood bar good people and homemade pastas, plus great bar food.

Excellent service and food

If in old forge, this is my Old forge style I like this the best out of all them, but there is better square out there, that isn't in old forge.

So good had a few cuts of pizza before heading to the airport. Oh if I could have Salerno's in CA I would never go back home

Great food ...cheap pizza and hot porchetta sandwiches

Great service , Good food!

Can't wait to come back for more pizza. Been too long. I told people in Niagara Falls New York that Old Forge Pizza is Better then anything in Niagara Falls and they thought I was joking till someone Googled Old Forge and found Greatest Pizza in the World. Three Hundred Mile Drive just to get there. Can't wait.

Great pizza and covered white. Offers dine in and take out cash or cards. Friendly staff and family friendly. Bar, booth or table (back dining area).

Been eating here since I was a kid. I never go anywhere else in Old Forge! It's our place to go after every football game and every basketball game!

Best gnocchi and pizza ever!

Great food, great atmosphere, excellent staff!

I Ate a Cheese Steak Hoagie and It Was Great

Called in at 12pm on 2-27-20. Asked if they delivered the lady on the phone rudely said no and hung up. I was willing to go pick the food up but never got a chance to place the order because of the unprofessionalism.

Stromboli is fantastic, and the musical guest Paul Laquintino's music was second to none.

Great food and service!

I think they have the Best Pizza here!!!! Very polite and nice employee's here. I love it!!!!

Our 1st visit to the "Pizza Capital of the world" was absolutely everything we wanted it to be (with Coronovirus lockdown expectations) we were sent here by our amazing Nurses @Taylor Moses NICU!! (Also the best) We ordered several Appts & several cuts. ALL were beyond expected flavor. Jalapeno Poppers , using local grown jalapenos homemade hand stuffed cheese & battered a MUST! Mozzarella sticks gooey, potato pancakes perfectly crunchy, it was ready when we arrived and were greeted with a very warm welcome. Wish we could have sat down, beautiful spot. The smell hit me as I walked up and when I opened the backdoor for pickup, another , stronger wave almost knocked me over. Thru my mandatory mask, I was still blown away and wanted to eat the air I was breathing. This was our 1st visit, of MANY more to come! Bravo!

The only place my granddaughter will eat several cuts of pizza. That in itself says something, as she is very picky. Always have a nice time here, food is good and servers are always friendly and nice. See you soon Salerno's.Baked ravioli with hot sausage is out of this world.

Great food nice atmosphere and great service

One of my favorite Old Forge restaurants. I love their porchetta sandwiches and I like their pasta sauce and antipasto. They also make delicious Tripe.

Best home made pasta!! See Anthony for some great Italian food. Made by real Italians!

Great spot. Its a little like stepping back in time. Great food. fairly priced. Highly recommended.

Grossest pizza I've ever had, but looks like a decent bar. Rating is strictly based on the pizza.

Amazing Italian Food The Best Ravs In Pa

Always good

Best country fried steak with sausage gravy Iever had

This pizza is soooooo good red or white double crust worth it

We love going to Selerno's for breakfast after Church on Sunday! So fun!

The food here is pretty good and the service is great. I would reccomend it.

Yummy food

My first time ever having there pizza, my pops told me it was great pizza back in the day. So I picked it up today, and the pizza was absolutely tasteful, and I would highly recommend them

Ordered over $100 worth of Food, and when we got our food the Hoagies were burnt and not made correctly, and the wings we ordered were supposed to be Mild but instead they gave us all Hot wings. Terrible experience. Would not recommend there wings at all.

I have a lot of history and great memories at Salerno's, Great food, pizza is the best!!

Another solid NEPA pizza experience. Unique.....light airy crust, crispy on the bottom, chewy in the middle. Good sauce/cheese ratio. Cheese is creamy, maybe mozzarella and American. Sticks to your teeth. Tomato Garlic Basil pie is excellent. Good wait staff and fairly inexpensive. Good choice.

A little pricey but their Pizza in food is delicious

Moved to MD from NEPA and most times I'm back I make sure we stop in. Great crust on the pizza and excellent homemade pasta!

I've been enjoying this spot for several years now. Most I can tell you is that EVERYTHING is good here! You won't be disappointed with anything. The pizza pictured is a Stuffed White Pizza With Broccoli. Whatever you choose to eat and drink you will be happy with, I can assure you of that. 😀

Great Old Forge pizza. Good to be home for the weekend

Love the pizza and Kat is wonderful!

Small local bar with very good pasta. Plus good pizza, burgers and more.

Our Favorite Place for Take Out! From Pizza to full Entree Dinners, They are THE Best! And IF There's a Problem, they are happy to correct it!

cold beer great food

Excellent Old Forge pizza! My mom loves the tripe.